17 Dishes That Should Be Banned from Black Thanksgiving

You had all season to buy yourself some soup from Panera so why would you bring that mess to the table?!

Every Black Thanksgiving has a set menu that rarely changes from year to year. With all of the essentials such as mac’ n cheese or collard greens, there are also a few given dishes that get the serious side eye when they appear on the table.

We don’t know what the white folks do over there but over here? We eat sweet potato pies, not pumpkin pies. We eat mac n’ cheese without breadcrumbs. We’d also prepare dishes in their original recipe versus throwing together several ingredients into a casserole.

If something new appears on the table, it may go untouched or you might be put on blast by the one cousin who shouts, “Who brought potato salad with raisins?!”

If you’re debating on what to bring to Thanksgiving this year, consider this list of 17 things not to bring and save yourself from the shame of returning home with the food you brought.

Stuffing, Not Dressing

Photo: Shutterstock Brent Hofacker

Don’t offend me. The two may appear similar but they are NOT the same. Give me dressing or nothing at all.

Green Bean Casserole

Photo: Shutterstock from my point of view

Amongst the several polls I sent out requesting ideas for this list, this abomination was at the top. The only acceptable form of green beans is with smoked turkey neck and potatoes. Why is it a trend to make this a casserole?

Mashed Potatoes

Photo: Shutterstock DronG

This may be debatable, but trust…you’ll never find this in my household. We have other things to hold gravy. Enter: rice, dressing, and of course, turkey.

Pumpkin Things

Photo: Getty Images istentiana

I don’t have anything against pumpkins for the rest of the Fall/Autumn season, but on Thanksgiving? This is strictly a sweet potato household. If I bite into a pie and it’s pumpkin, we might have to fight.

Canned Greens

Photo: Getty Images Douglas Sacha

As a little girl, I sat in the kitchen snapping green beans and watching my grandmother clean the collards. You think I don’t know the difference between fresh and canned vegetables?

Boxed Gravy

Photo: Getty Images Creativ Studio Heinemann

We can tell the difference. There are too many leftover greases and turkey juices for you to not be able to make a gravy. Leave that flavorless roux home.

Beyond Meats

Photo: Getty Images mrs

On any other day, I will embrace vegan alternatives. But please don’t play with my pork chops and turkey wings.

Spaghetti

Photo: Getty Images Aleksandr Zubkov

Are you crazy? Your kids have been eating spaghetti for the past week and that’s what you bring to the feast of feasts?!

Broccoli-Cheddar Whatever

Photo: Getty Images LauriPatterson

I get it. Tis’ the season to embrace all variations of broccoli-cheddar dishes. But do us a favor and leave your lunch for work in the fridge.

Soup

Photo: Getty Images Chris Cantòn

Why?

Sugar- or Gluten-Free Sweets

Photo: Getty Images Huw Jones

This is the one time of year to not be shy on the sugar and gluten. Even if you’re trying to be conscious of the one guest who has a dietary restriction, please, let the rest of us enjoy ourselves.

Fruit Cake

Photo: Getty Images Anouk Stricher

The main desserts include pie, cobblers, banana pudding and maybe a pound cake. If you walk in with a fruit cake, you will also leave with that fruit cake.

Creamed Spinach

Photo: Getty Images mjrodafotografia

Why? You’re better off bringing artichoke dip for us to snack on while we wait for the food. No one is putting this on their plate.

Pizza

Photo: Shutterstock Tanya Sid

If you walk through the door with a double cheese pepperoni stuffed crust pie, trade your “Happy Thanksgiving” for an apology.

Vegetable Trays

Photo: Shutterstock FocalPointPhotoWI

If you didn’t allot enough time to cook, just say that. I’ll starve all day till 4 p.m. instead of snack on raw carrots and broccoli. At least bring a char-whatever-it-is board.

Boxed Wine

Photo: Getty Images Ole Schwander

Why would you come in this house with this excuse of a wine? If you cheap just say that.

Whatever You Know You’re Not In Charge Of…

Photo: Getty Images annick vanderschelden photography

Every family has the one relative they can count on for a prominent Thanksgiving dish. If grandma makes the mac n’ cheese every year, please don’t consider this your moment to play Hell’s Kitchen.

Straight From The Root

Sign up for our free daily newsletter.

Latest from The Root

Photo by Monstera Production:

Books by Black LGBTQ+ Authors To Explore This Pride Month

In honor of Pride Month 2025, we’ve some of our favorite books by Black LGBTQ+ authors …
Prom Looks

The Most Boldest and Outrageous 2025 Prom Looks

From Disney cosplay attire to beautiful proposal, we are sharing our favorite prom send offs …