It seems like every other week, we’re getting news of one of our favorite shows saying sayonara to our small screens thanks to mergers or budget cuts or any number of reasons (looking at you, specifically “Rap Sh!t,” “Truth Be Told,” and “Love Life”). This not only makes for upset fans who already found themselves attached to these short-lived characters, but it also serves an injustice to the aforementioned characters’ storylines and arcs as we’ll never get closure or a proper send-off to their sagas.
That being said, we felt it fitting to take a look back at several shows that got canceled far too soon and deserved at least one more season.
Suggested Reading
“How to Die Alone”
One of the more recent shows to get the boot, “Insecure” star Natasha Rothwell’s new show “How to Die Alone” won’t be coming back for a second season. But the good news is that doesn’t mean we won’t get to see her on our screens anymore as she’ll be starring in the upcoming new season of the “The White Lotus.”
“Unprisoned”
“Unprisoned,” the Kerry Washington, Delroy Lindo-starring dramedy series really hit a good stride in season two. It’s a shame we won’t get to see that story evolve even more.
“61st Street”
With stars like Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor and Courtney B. Vance, you would think a show like “61st street” would stand a good chance at seeing multiple seasons. Sadly, that wasn’t the case as the show was cancelled after the first one.
“All American: Homecoming”
“All American: Homecoming” couldn’t live up to it’s predecessor’s success but it still found a loyal fanbase and received great reviews. Unfortunately, that wasn’t enough to save the show as is it won’t be returning for a fourth season.
“Black Cake”
Hulu’s “Black Cake” was arguably one of the most intriguing shows they had on their platform. There was more that could’ve been done and more that should’ve been explored in a second season.
“Bel-Air”
Though some of us still can’t believe it, “Bel-Air” will be concluding after the fourth season. For what it’s worth, the entire cast should be proud but man, oh man, I thought they’d at least hit five seasons before saying goodbye.
“Girlfriends”
Though there’s circulating talk about a potential reboot, we’re still salty about the way things ended. And do we really have to say why? We need the show creators to run it back ASAP!
“Riches”
When news broke that Prime Video’s drama series “Riches” wouldn’t return for a second season, much sadness and shock hit both fans and the cast. Lead actress Deborah Ayorinde thanked her supporters for showing up for the storytelling, writing in a post to Instagram:
“I’m so grateful to be a performer at such as time as this where shows like Riches, exist. It is incredibly important that you, the audience continue to use your power, let your voices be heard loud and clear and let it be known what you love and want to see.
I am so, so, so proud of what we created and I want to thank Abby Ajayi for creating Riches and including me in her vision. I want to thank Prime Video for championing the show and me as a performer and I want to thank all of you for all of your love and support for the show and my art in general. Much, much love.
“Rap Sh!t”
JUSTICE FOR MY SEDUCIN’ AND SCHEMIN’ PARTNERS MIA AND SHAWNA! Rap Sh!t’s cancellation on Thursday was met with universal outrage, sadness and shock by fans and the creative teams behind it—and for good reason! The growth between season one and season two was noticeable and everyone involved delivered and brought us so much potential that we’ll now never see fully realized and cliffhanger plots get resolved. A lot of the cancellations on this list hurt but this one really feels like a dagger.
“Bigger”
This gem of a show was on BET+ but it came with good characters and good storylines and it’s too bad that we didn’t get to see their evolution.
“Run the World”
I almost feel like we can’t have nice things because for STARZ to cancel this after it was proven it had a growing fan base is still one of the most puzzling things ever!
“Love Life”
I can’t tell you how many times I’m constantly hearing people talk about how robbed they feel by not getting to see the evolution of William Harper Jackson and Jessica Williams’ relationship in “Love Life.” And you know what? They’re right.
“Our Kind of People”
Morris Chestnut. Yaya DaCosta. Rhyon Nicole Brown. Lance Gross. Debbi Morgan. Joe Morton. McKinley Freeman.
We got all these beautifully melanated people and talent in one show and we didn’t get a second season???!!
“Swagger”
Let’s move on to an equally strong series on AppleTV+, the gem that is Swagger. News of its recent cancellation took Twitter/X by storm last Thursday, prompting many to express their love for the series. In a statement from his own personal page, creator Reggie Rock Bythewood said in part: “In our two seasons, we have launched careers, disrupted genre, brought forth humanity through our characters, told stories we deeply care about, revolutionized the way to shoot basketball and have fun. That’s a blessing.”
You know what would be a bigger blessing, Apple?? BRINGING BACK THE SHOW. Be like Spike Lee and do the right thing!
“Love Is___”
OWN’s one-season-wonder: Love Is_, inspired by the love story of TV-producing couple Salim and Mara Brock Akil, took the internet by storm and garnered a huge following in near record time. While it wasn’t without its flaws, the love and career success story of Yasir and Nuri is one that we still need to see evolve. Somebody get Oprah on the line, the streets need this!!
“The Get Down”
Just the fact that I’ll never get to see Yahya Abdul-Mateen II disco dance as Cadillac or hear Shameik Moore scream “I’M SHAOLIN FANTASTIC, THE LADY KILLING ROMANTIC” ever again is enough to make me cry into the next millennium. Netflix’s The Get Down was gone far too soon.
“South Side”
I don’t think I’ve cried laughing or screamed laughing at a show like HBO Max’s South Side in a looooooong time. Its cancellation was a miss entirely.
“Raising Dion”
A Black kid superhero learning how to harness his powers for good with the support of his mother? Come on, now. Netflix knows good and well that we needed another season of Raising Dion.
“Legendary”
Not only was Legendary fabulous but it was also edu-taining, meaning educational and entertaining. More folks needed to learn a thing or two about ballroom culture, how to respect it and how to serve, if we’re being real. This show was giving what it was supposed to have gave and I’m sick that HBO Max put an end to it.
“The Mayor”
I think I audibly gasped when the news broke that the ABC show The Mayor had been canceled. Brandon Michael Hall, Bernard David Jones, and Marcel Spears were like my favorite trio of friends. Not seeing them together on my screen anymore is a huge miss.
“Survivor’s Remorse”
Not only was STARZ’s Survivor’s Remorse great, but it boasts a handful of our 90s favorite actors like Tichina Arnold and Ronreaco Lee and Teyonah Parris and Jesse T. Usher.
“Underground”
Aldis Hodge. Jurnee Smollett. Amirah Vahn. Aisha Hinds. Alano Miller. Need I say more about WGN’s Underground?
“The Arsenio Hall Show”
Come on now, it’s Arsenio freakin’ Hall. He had the goods for TV and when the show was revived in 2013, they should’ve given our guy more time.
“The Carmichael Show”
The Carmichael Show was another show that made me audibly gasp when its cancellation was announced. I know the comedic style wasn’t everybody’s cup of tea, but you cannot deny the chemistry between Jerrod Carmichael, Lil Rel, David Alan Grier, Loretta Devine, Tiffany Haddish and more.
“Roc”
Those who watched Fox back in the early 90s will remember how much Roc was a gem of a show and also why it never got its just dues.
“She’s Gotta Have It”
Admittedly, season two of this Netflix show wasn’t as good as the first one IN MY OPINION. But that doesn’t mean we didn’t deserve to see more of Nola Darling and her evolution.
“My Brother and Me”
Nickelodeon-Hive, stand up! This classic show was important to an entire generation of kids and we should’ve gotten more from it.
“The Sinbad Show”
There’s a reason Sinbad was so popular—and that’s because he was so good and so funny. The people wanted more and we should’ve gotten it!
“Lovecraft Country”
Scandal involving its lead star aside, not a week goes by where someone online isn’t venting their frustrations about not getting a season two of this show. It’s only right that they get what they’ve so long been waiting for.
“A Black Lady Sketch Show”
There aren’t too many show cancellation’s that make me sad but this one was definitely one of them. Why? Because when was the last time you saw a Black woman-created, led, and produced comedy sketch show? Exactly. Robin Thede’s show was both barrier-breaking and funny and I hope it gets revived soon.
“Grand Crew”
Another easy-watch that delivered on laughs and storylines, Grand Crew was a good time and one that deserved to keep telling its stories for awhile.
“A League of Their Own”
I’ve got two words for you: Chante Adams. She deserves to be on our screens way more than she has been and this show proved why.
“Winning Time: The Rise of the Lakers Dynasty”
While the second season of the show garnered some online criticism from former players and coaches, what’s undeniable is that it was damn good TV that has the potential to tell more stories. Here’s hoping another platform picks it up.
“The Wonder Years”
Only running for two seasons, The Wonder Years was a breath of fresh air, giving new perspective on an old classic. We still want to see where the Williams family goes from here.
“Ziwe”
Given all the foolery that’s currently happening in this country, we were robbed another two or 12 seasons of Ziwe to help bring the laugh and much needed correction and shade to us all. Somebody get my girl back on TV!
“L.A.’S Finest”
A Spectrum Original, “L.A.’s Finest” starring Gabrielle Union and Jessica Alba was a spinoff of the “Bad Boys” franchise and was such good television (especially the season one finale), the news of it’s non-renewal was such a shock to the system—I’m still upset about it nearly three years later.
“Truth Be Told”
Starring Octavia Spencer and also Gabrielle Union, “Truth Be Told” tells the story of true crime podcaster Poppy Parnell, who is called to investigate the case of convicted killer Warren Cave, a man she incriminated after he murdered the father of two identical twins. Soon, Parnell must decide where the lines between guilty and innocent lie when Cave confesses to the fact that he was framed for the crime. Between the storyline and acting, this show deserved more air time and viewers.
“Flatbush Misdemeanors”
A comedy centered on two guys struggling to adjust in their new surroundings of Flatbush, Brooklyn, the series was canceled after two seasons.
“Kindred”
Based off the novel of the same name by Octavia Butler, Kindred tells the story of a young black woman and aspiring writer has uprooted her life of familial obligation and relocated to Los Angeles. Before she can settle into her new home, she finds herself being violently pulled back and forth in time.
The series only aired for one season before being canceled.
“Blindspotting”
Starring Daveed Diggs, Blindspotting was the sequel spinoff to the 2018 film of the same name which followed a parolee with three days left on his sentence who witnesses a police shooting that threatens to ruin a lifelong friendship.
The series only aired for two seasons before being canceled.
“Saturdays”
Executive produced by Marsai Martin and Norman Vance Jr. (who recently won an NAACP Image Award this year), “Saturdays” is a single-cam coming of age comedy that only takes place on the best day of the week! The series revolves around 14-year-old, Paris Johnson, and her best friends Simone & Ari, who hone their roller skating skills on the cool parquet floor of Saturdays, a local skating rink in Chicago. Together they form the We-B-Girlz skate crew and are determined to show and prove they have the hottest skate routines on the planet!
“The Underground Railroad”
Now this show didn’t necessarily get cancelled, but it won’t be returning for a second season. That fact is a bit disappointing because that means we don’t get to see Barry Jenkins’ genius on our screens. But hopefully the tide will turn soon.
Insecure
I know we’re blessed that this show even saw five seasons to begin with but when it comes to “Insecure,” I only have four words to say: “BRING. MY. GIRLS. BACK.”
Straight From 
Sign up for our free daily newsletter.